Reserve · Banana Pudding

Order Banana Pudding, Cake or Cheesecake

The Southern classic, made two ways. Choose the layer cake or the cheesecake, and we will bake it fresh for your date.

1 Your details
2 Your cake

Everything is baked fresh, so orders need at least 1 week's notice, the earliest date you can choose is 7 days out. Need it sooner? Call us at (770) 573-0199, rush fees apply ($7.99-$100 by complexity).

Pick a time within our store hours (Mon-Sat). Hours vary by day, so we'll confirm your exact pickup time when we reply.

Cheesecakes are priced above the standard cake chart. We will confirm your price when we reply.

Your price includes up to 2 icing colors, additional colors are an added charge. We match shades as closely as we can, but an exact match to a photo or a past cake can't be guaranteed.

3 A reference photo (optional)

Add it here and we'll use it as our guide.

Payment and deposit policy. Baking begins only after payment has been received, so we ask that your order be paid in full before it goes into production. When a deposit is arranged to reserve your date, that deposit is non-refundable, as ingredients are purchased specifically for your order. Any remaining balance is due before pickup.

Questions, or need a cake sooner than a week out? Call us at (770) 573-0199.

Banana Pudding Cake and Cheesecake, Baked to Order

Banana pudding is a standing request in this part of Georgia, and we make it two ways: as a layer cake and as a cheesecake. Both are baked from scratch to order at our Main Street bakery in Tucker, so you are getting a whole dessert made for your date rather than something scooped from a tray.

It travels well and it feeds a crowd, which is why it turns up at cookouts, church functions, and family dinners all over metro Atlanta. See the full menu for every flavor we bake, or the cheesecake page for the other fourteen cheesecake flavors.

Frequently asked questions

Do you sell banana pudding near me in Atlanta?

We bake it at 2319 Main Street, Tucker, GA 30084, about 20 minutes northeast of downtown Atlanta. Order using the form above or call (770) 573-0199, and pick it up at the bakery.

Is it a pudding or a cake?

We make banana pudding as a layer cake and as a cheesecake, not as a scooped pudding in a tray. Both carry the flavor people are after, in a form you can slice and serve.

Which should I pick for a party?

The layer cake is the easier crowd-pleaser and follows our standard size chart, so an 8 inch serves about 20 party slices. The cheesecake is richer and denser, so people usually take smaller slices. Tell us your headcount in the notes and we will point you to the right one.

How much does it cost?

The layer cake follows the standard size chart, starting at $29.99 for an 8 inch. The cheesecake is priced above that chart. Both are starting prices that vary by size, and we will quote yours within one business day.

How much notice do you need?

At least one week, since everything is baked fresh to order. Call (770) 573-0199 if your date is sooner and we will tell you what is possible.