Cheesecakes, From New Yorker to Guava

Fifteen flavors baked from scratch, regular or gluten-free.

Golden cheesecake topped with strawberries, blackberries, whipped cream, and a black Mr and Mrs silhouette topperBerry-Topped Mr & Mrs Cheesecake
Cheesecake with a vibrant red glaze top, white drizzle design, and golden crumb crustRed-Glazed Cheesecake with White Drizzle
See the full gallery

Reserve · Cheesecakes

Order a Cheesecake, Made From Scratch

Fifteen flavors, from the classic New Yorker to guava and strawberry pineapple, and yes, we make gluten-free cheesecakes too.

1 Your details
2 Your cake

Everything is baked fresh, so orders need at least 1 week's notice, the earliest date you can choose is 7 days out. Need it sooner? Call us at (770) 573-0199, rush fees apply ($7.99-$100 by complexity).

Pick a time within our store hours (Mon-Sat). Hours vary by day, so we'll confirm your exact pickup time when we reply.

Gluten-free cheesecakes are priced a little higher because of the specialty crust.

Signs and toppers are $3.99 each.

3 A reference photo (optional)

Add it here and we'll use it as our guide.

Payment and deposit policy. Baking begins only after payment has been received, so we ask that your order be paid in full before it goes into production. When a deposit is arranged to reserve your date, that deposit is non-refundable, as ingredients are purchased specifically for your order. Any remaining balance is due before pickup.

Questions, or need a cake sooner than a week out? Call us at (770) 573-0199.

Fifteen Cheesecake Flavors, Baked to Order

We bake fifteen cheesecake flavors from scratch, from the classic New Yorker to guava, Heath candy, mango, cherry, and strawberry pineapple. Every flavor can be made regular or gluten-free.

Cheesecake is where this bakery started, it is the recipe Pat built Cakes Castle on. See the full flavor list, read her story on Meet Pat, or browse the gallery.

Frequently asked questions

What cheesecake flavors do you have?

Fifteen: banana pudding, blueberry, cherry, chocolate orange, chocolate swirl, coconut, guava, Heath candy, key lime, mango, New Yorker, pineapple, raspberry, strawberry, and strawberry pineapple.

Do you make gluten-free cheesecake?

Yes, every cheesecake flavor can be made regular or gluten-free.

How are cheesecakes priced?

Cheesecakes are priced above the standard cake chart, and those are starting prices that vary by flavor and size. Send a request and we will quote yours.

How much notice do you need?

Cheesecakes are baked to order, so at least one week's notice is best. Call (770) 573-0199 for sooner.